Skip to main content

Question 8.6

Solutions

TZ
leumasicOfficial

3 months ago

a) Suppose for contradiction that this were not so; that there exists bb such that f(b)=l0f(b)=l\ne 0.

Since ff is continuous, there exists δ>0\delta>0 such that

f(x)l<l    f(x)>0|f(x)-l|<|l| \implies |f(x)|>0

for all x(bδ,b+δ)x\in(b-\delta,b+\delta). Since this is an open interval, there would be a number aa in it. But this contradicts the premise that f(y)=0f(y)=0 for all yy in AA.

b) Let h(x)=f(x)g(x)h(x)=f(x)-g(x). Since hh is continuous and h(x)=0h(x)=0 for all numbers xx in a dense set AA, by a) we have that h(x)=0h(x)=0 for all xx. But this means that f(x)g(x)=0f(x)-g(x)=0 and therefore f(x)=g(x)f(x)=g(x) for all xx.

c) Suppose for contradiction that there exists bb such that f(b)<g(b)f(b)<g(b). We have limxbf(x)=f(b)\lim_{x\to b}f(x)=f(b) and limxbg(x)=g(b)\lim_{x\to b}g(x)=g(b). These limits are defined since ff and gg are continuous. Moreover, there exist δ1,δ2>0\delta_1,\delta_2>0 such that

f(x)f(b)<g(b)f(b)2|f(x)-f(b)|<\frac{g(b)-f(b)}{2}

for all x(bδ1,b+δ1)x\in(b-\delta_1,b+\delta_1) and

g(x)g(b)<g(b)f(b)2|g(x)-g(b)|<\frac{g(b)-f(b)}{2}

for all x(bδ2,b+δ2)x\in(b-\delta_2,b+\delta_2).

Let δ=min(δ1,δ2)\delta=\min(\delta_1,\delta_2). Combining both inequalities, we have that f(x)<g(x)f(x)<g(x) for all x(bδ,b+δ)x\in(b-\delta,b+\delta). Since this is an open interval, there exists yAy\in A with y(bδ,b+δ)y\in(b-\delta,b+\delta). But this contradicts the premise that f(x)g(x)f(x)\ge g(x) for all xAx\in A.

We cannot replace \ge with >>. As a counterexample, consider f(x)=xf(x)=x and g(x)=0g(x)=0 on the dense set A={x:xR, x0}A=\{x:x\in\mathbb{R},\ x\ne 0\}. Obviously, x>0x>0 for all xAx\in A with x>0x>0, but not for x=0x=0.

0
Submit a solution
Optional • Markdown

Sign in to share your solution for this question.

Sign in

Navigate

Q 8.6

Navigate

Q 8.6