Skip to main content

Question 7.13

Solutions

TZ
leumasicOfficial

3 months ago

a) The function f(x)f(x) is not continuous on [1,1][-1,1] because its limit at x=0x=0 does not exist. However, ff is continuous on [1,0)[-1,0) and (0,1](0,1], so we can apply the IVT on these intervals. For intervals [a,b][a,b] with a0ba\le0\le b, ff takes on all values in [1,1][-1,1], so it surely takes all values between f(a)f(a) and f(b)f(b).

b) For contradiction, suppose ff is not continuous. Consider the point x=ax=a. This means that there exists ε>0\varepsilon>0 such that for all δ>0\delta>0, there is an xx with xa<δ|x-a|<\delta and f(x)f(a)ε|f(x)-f(a)|\ge\varepsilon. Without loss of generality, suppose

f(x)f(a)ε,f(x)-f(a)\ge\varepsilon,

so that f(x)f(a)+εf(x)\ge f(a)+\varepsilon, and x>ax>a. By the IVT, there exists β\beta such that f(β)=cf(\beta)=c for f(a)<c<f(a)+εf(a)<c<f(a)+\varepsilon. Now, we can find another point yy by shrinking δ\delta so as to exclude the points xx and β\beta from [yδ,y+δ][y-\delta,y+\delta]. In this interval, we also have f(y)f(a)ε|f(y)-f(a)|\ge\varepsilon. But if f(y)f(a)εf(y)-f(a)\ge\varepsilon, then f(y)f(a)+εf(y)\ge f(a)+\varepsilon, and by the IVT, ff takes on the same values in (y,β)(y,\beta) as it does in (β,x)(\beta,x). A similar contradiction arises if f(a)f(y)εf(a)-f(y)\ge\varepsilon instead.

c) We can repeat the interval-generating process in b), where ff repeatedly takes on the same values, thus contradicting the hypothesis.

0
Submit a solution
Optional • Markdown

Sign in to share your solution for this question.

Sign in

Navigate

Q 7.13

Navigate

Q 7.13